By Dan Kennedy • The press, politics, technology, culture and other passions

Protection racket

Here’s something most of you already know, but which news reports like this one consistently miss: The digital-rights-management scheme on music sold by Apple’s iTunes Store is so weak that it’s scarcely worth mentioning.

It’s pretty simple: (1) Download a copy-protected song or an album from iTunes; (2) burn it onto a CD, which you are allowed to do. That’s it. The CD is as free of copy protection as one you would buy in a store. Thus you can re-rip it to any format you like.

Which means that I can’t see why people are so excited about the deal announced yesterday by Apple and EMI.

Discover more from Media Nation

Subscribe to get the latest posts to your email.


Musical columnists


D’oh! It’s McGrory on Sundays


  1. dan zarrella

    Trans-coding like that will mean you’ll loose quality.

  2. Mike P

    I agree with the previous commenter. People are forgetting what music is supposed to sound like. Compare an MP3 (or Apple’s own AAC format) of a song produced in the last 10 years to a good vinyl copy of a song recorded a few decades ago and it’s no contest. The technology is getting better – SACD and DVD-Audio are advances, but until we get it so that mp3s sound that good, most music will sound terrible.

  3. man who hates DRM

    I think people are excited mostly because the record labels and RIAA have made such a big deal about music privacy and DRM for many years now. It’s been such a monolithic drumbeat that any sort of “crack in the dam” is viewed as “only the beginning”.People have been predicting the death of the traditional music distribution/promotion/rights model for over a decade now. This could be a big step into that open grave.Or at least that’s what many anti-DRM fans are fervently hoping.And Dan Zarrella is right – that method means you will lose at least some audio quality. Potentially enough to annoy Joe Average if the wrong ripping codec is used. Plus it’s a hassle to burn a CD only to re-rip it again. Joe Average doesn’t like hassle.

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén