At long last, I got to see “Page One: Inside the New York Times” at a screening last night at Harvard’s Shorenstein Center. It’s a terrifically entertaining look at the culture inside the Times newsroom, focusing on the media desk’s coverage of the newspaper meltdown of 2009 and ’10. I brought a couple of students with me, and they were pretty enthusiastic about it as we were driving back to Northeastern.
As you have no doubt heard, the stars are columnist David Carr and reporter Brian Stelter, two people whose talents, though formidable, pale in comparison to their inhuman productivity. Carr easily slips into the role of Carr, a late-middle-aged reformed drug addict who genially F-bombs his way through interviews and public appearances, building up to his monumental takedown of Tribune Co. and its abusive owner, Sam Zell. Stelter, young and earnest, is the perfect counterpoint. (I know both of them slightly, Carr better than Stelter.)
Director Andrew Rossi and Shorenstein Center director Alex Jones kicked it around afterwards.
An obsessive media junkie probably won’t learn much, but I really enjoyed being immersed in Timesland for 90 minutes. Quibbles? As a friend observed, the documentary was heavily tilted toward men, which seems odd given that before it ends, we see the executive editor’s baton being passed from Bill Keller to Jill Abramson.
And though it was unavoidable, the sense of panic that pervaded the business when the film was being shot has abated to at least some degree. We’re hardly out of the woods. It seems that every day, we hear about cost-cutting and layoffs. But the notion that was prevalent a year or two ago, that the entire newspaper business was in its death throes, now appears to have been exaggerated. If “Page One” were shot today, I suspect it would be more optimistic.
Discover more from Media Nation
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Page One is entertaining but I thought Carr was trying too hard to come off as Hunter S. Thompson lite – a lovable eccentric. He also says things that surprised me – like promising a source that a story would get on A1. And the focus on the media desk obscured issues that could have been more insightful, such as how the Times covers foreign or national news. The discussion about whether the last combat troops were “really” leaving Iraq and how they should play it was more interesting to me.
Esther: I can’t say I know Carr well, but my experience is that’s not an act.
I also saw PAGE ONE this week (on Apple TV) and enjoyed it. I’d like to see David Carr and Tim Arango in their jobs for years to come, so I hope they stop smoking. They were puffing away in what seemed to be nearly every scene.
Esther, I shared your surprise. I guess that’s why I never got recruited by the Times.