
An independent news organization in the Chicago suburbs has filed a copyright-infringement suit against Surround Sound Media, a company that uses AI to produce some 175 local news outlets across the country.
Sign up for free email delivery of Media Nation — and become a supporter for just $6 a month.
The Record North Shore, a nonprofit based in Wilmette, Illinois, that covers eight communities, claims Surround Sound’s North Shore Weekly “systematically and improperly republished The Record’s original reporting and photography.” The lawsuit, filed in U.S. District Court, asks for an injunction to prevent future acts of copyright infringement, the removal of copyrighted materials and monetary damages of up to $25,000 per incident.
Also named as a defendant is Robert Kellman, who is reportedly the founder of Surround Sound Media. A Surround Sound official, Hilary Loewenstein, told The Record by email that she had “no comment” on the lawsuit, although a statement from the company says that its news outlets use a combination of AI and real journalists, with journalists having the final say.
The Record’s own story about the lawsuit quotes editor-in-chief Joe Coughlin:
We work really hard to produce independent and original local news every single day, and we allege that that work was used inappropriately and without authorization. Those alleged actions are a threat to the work itself, to the work of small publishers, and to the community that relies upon that work and that credible information.
With AI-generated local news encroaching on communities that are already being covered by actual journalists, in many cases employed by struggling independent start-ups, The Record’s lawsuit will no doubt be watched closely. The Record itself was founded in 2020 and is a substantial operation, with four full-time staff members and $440,000 in revenues in 2025. The project was recently highlighted as a “Bright Spot” by the Local News Initiative at Northwestern University’s Medill School.
One challenge The Record will face is that facts can’t be copyrighted, only a specific expression of those facts. If North Shore Weekly is rewriting The Record’s stories, whether with AI or by humans, then there may not be much The Record can do. That particular practice, after all, goes back decades, even centuries. Word-by-word copying, however, would constitute plagiarism and might also be regarded as copyright violation.
Republishing photos would make for an easier case, and The Record’s lawsuit says that North Shore Weekly has done that, too.
Last week, Maggie Scales of The Lexington Observer reported on similar tactics by Surround Sound Media in its Lexington-Concord Courier, including several stories that appeared to have been rewritten versions of articles that had first appeared in the Observer. Surround Sound also provided Scales with a statement that is identical to one it gave The Record. It said in part:
In our hybrid newsrooms, journalists set the coverage agenda, choose sources and make the final decisions about what we publish. AI tools help monitor public records, identify developments and prepare drafts, which journalists check against source material, edit and put into context before publication.
- Earlier: “How to fight back against AI-generated news and pink slime: double down on civic engagement” (Nov. 13)
Discover more from Media Nation
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
All the best to Record North Shore. Last week I got a plea traced to Surround Sound Media asking of I wanted to be editor of its new outlet in Arlington, MA. Not a chance. I’ve been happy with YourArlington, a site that uses human reporters since 2006. NU grad Carol Beggy has been in charge for two years.
Bob Sprague