The New York Times’ latest overheated reporting about Mary Peltola raises some questions

Mary Peltola. Photo is in the public domain.

I want to make three points about The New York Times’ report that the campaign of Alaska Democratic Senate candidate Mary Peltola recruited a ringer named Dan Sullivan to take votes away from her rival, the incumbent Republican, who is also named Dan Sullivan.

Sign up for free email delivery of Media Nation — and become a supporter for just $6 a month.

First, why did Elisa Rios, the Times’ main source, retract what she told them? “As discussed on our call earlier today, I am confirming that I have retracted all statements made regarding the 2026 Alaska Senate Race in connection with any article you may or may not be writing,” Rios wrote. “I am not willing to be a source for any story in any capacity.” I know the Times says they verified the story independently, but what was that all about?

Second, the Times reports: “When Ms. Peltola ran for re-election to the House two years ago, the state Republican Party backed an effort to help a Democrat — an inmate who ran his campaign from a New York prison — stay on the ballot.” I don’t remember hearing anything about that at the time, and it sounds a lot more serious than what the Peltola campaign is accused of doing.

Third, this story follows a gratuitous hit job on Peltola that the Times published last month, including the shocking revelation that her aides were required to feed live crickets to her daughter’s chameleon, Meatball. That story includes this detail, which, if nothing else, is pretty entertaining:

On at least one occasion, the crickets escaped in the office and had to be recaptured, according to two former aides who witnessed it as well as a photo viewed by The Times that showed aides in the office trying to trap the crickets using manila folders and small paper cups.

The horror!

Finally, the Times has published a follow-up reporting that Alaska’s Republican governor, Mike Dunleavy, is ordering a criminal investigation despite the lack of any evidence that recruiting a ringer is illegal. I urge you to read it. You’ll struck by the dismissive tone. For instance:

[T]he Peltola campaign is hardly the first political committee on either side of the aisle to engage in ballot-stacking.

Many Democrats defended the plan by pointing out how commonplace such actions are. Republicans have employed them in a variety of states, including Alaska.

Some Democrats even said that the intricate plot was a welcome sign that the party was fighting tooth and nail to oppose Mr. Trump’s agenda in what they viewed as an existential election.

Is the Times now trying to walk back its own overheated reporting?


Discover more from Media Nation

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

5 thoughts on “The New York Times’ latest overheated reporting about Mary Peltola raises some questions”

  1. I think you make excellent points here. I also feel what the Dems did in Alaska is dishonest and helps destroy people’s faith in politics and elections (and yes, the Republicans do it just as much). I think there’s a danger both of overplaying this story and of excusing/ignoring this behavior just because it’s done by the side generally battling a fascist effort to end our democracy. With your critique in mind, I still applaud the Times from not shying away from it, even if they sometimes go overboard trying (in vain) to prove to skeptics that they are evenhanded in shining a light on the powerful.

    1. It’s the lack of proportionality more than anything. I think they know it. Their follow-up reads like they’re pissing on their own story.

      1. I was shocked at the lack of actual reporting in the story. I have yet to discover any factual reason for the recent firings of Rios and other longtime staffers. Why were they fired? Why would the NYT publish such an article in the midst of active voting in Alaska when the author had collected his “facts” before early voting began, but failed to investigate and report exactly why his sources had been fired by Peltola? Were Rios and the anonymous sources themselves culpable for instigating the alleged actions by Peltola and the Democratic Party, seeing as they were the ones in charge of the campaign at that time? Did the author consider the possibility of threats or payments from the Trump Administration to these sources and how that may have impacted the timing of the Rios retraction? Why was the Rio retraction buried in the middle of the article when it should have been a disclaimer at the beginning? That placement of crucial information immediately made me skeptical of every claim made by the author. It appeared to be an obvious hit job designed to tank Peltola’s slight lead in the polls. Shades of the Hilary emails to me. I am very disillusioned by the NYT’s decision to publish these allegations when it did.

  2. This was sloppy, lazy reporting at best. And it certainly should never have been the subject of The Daily just days before the election. Cricketgate and Dan Sullivan-gate are beyond ridiculous given that in the last few days we have new information about rape allegations against Trump from the former Miss Switzerland, blatant lies in Michigan about the Muslim Brotherhood, the disgusting ad run in Ohio by Vivek, and the U.S. helping Bolsonaro escape from Brazil.

  3. The source’s retraction deserves a clearer explanation. Readers need to know which parts of her account the Times could verify independently before they can judge how much weight to give the story.

Comments are closed.